
why I hate Stellarlune and my honest opinion on why the series is going downhill
So, don’t get me wrong. I love KotLC, and I’ll always love it! My review on 3 other KotLC books kinda proves that! But literally, Miss Messenger…… another one?! What, are you trying to break the record for the longest series ever written?! The fact is, KotLC is stretching way too long at this point. I waited for a year for Stellarlune and what did I get? Another 800-page book which was 60% just filler! I mean apart from a few plot developments (yayyyy sokeefe fans out there!! we did it!!) there was literally nothing! Finally, over the course of 2 years and 10 books, I have lost patience. It was ultimately almost totally useless to the plot. Fine, we got to know who glimmer is! And guess what? It’s someone we have never heard of before! The entire book is basically everyone stressing over stuff they don’t do anything to control and when Sophie does it, well, more on that later. The whole thing is way too idealistic (this is supposed to be a super serious problem for the elves, one that can endanger everything, and no one major has died yet? I mean come onnnnnn) the whole Mr. Forkle twin thing was totally unnecessary (I do not like him. At all.) He’s dead, let him be dead for God’s sake! Why do you have to bring him back to life in some form (the twin) and not even just because I hated him! He was like a father to Sophie and his dying would have given the series so much weight. Sophie would have a purpose to defeat the Neverseen – revenge! But noooooo he’s still there! The quality of the worldbuilding which hooked me from the first book has practically become non-existent. The Black Swan is a totally useless organisation which does absolutely nothing and (as I was saying) when Sophie actually tries to do something they become all philosophical and huffy. And that is why the elven world is in such a crisis! Because of these totally useless Black Swans and Councils. At this point, I honestly feel like I’m rooting for the Neverseen. At least they do something. The only thing I actually care about anymore is the characters. The team dynamics are basically the saving grace of this series by now. I want to root for Tam and Linh and the rest but the plot has just gone in 10 different directions and I don’t even know what the aim of the Black Swan and the Neverseen even is now. Why on Earth are there even more mysteries being revealed NOW, in the supposedly second last book? Unless of course there are 5 more books coming out. I feel like it could have been such an amazing series and it was, for a few books! The thing is, from the beginning of KotLC there was this kind of pull, an obsession to find out what happens next. That pull is just zero now. Maybe I’ve just grown old, but I don’t think that’s it. I think that it was a great series with lots of potential, but it just keeps going downhill with each book in my opinion. It’s getting way too lengthy with way too many plot holes and I feel like even the storyline doesn’t know where it’s going anymore. Maybe I expected way too much from Stellarlune in the first place, but this is my honest opinion. For a person who wanted to read it and bought it the day it came out, this is surprising. Maybe this was what I’ve thought all along and just realised. Maybe. I don’t know. Basically, what I feel is that it fell from 5 star to 1 star from the first to the latest book, and the reason that even the 1 star is there is basically because of sokeefe and the team. I’ll probably read the last book for old times’ sake, but I fully expect to be disappointed.
Stellarlune –